So: A black guy, a lesbian and a Jew walk into a bar. If you’re over 40 you’ve no doubt heard a joke like this. It’s a genre of humour that reached its zenith in the 1970s. By the 1980s you had to be careful. People weren’t laughing at these jokes like they used to. Indeed, by the 1990s they were shared in hushed tones within strict company.
We’ve come a long way.
Or have we? Is it possible we’ve turned a corner only to find ourselves right back where we started? A generational divide now exists. If you know a joke about three minorities, then you’re probably too old to know what a Dirty Sanchez is. And if you know what a Dirty Sanchez is, then you don’t find jokes about Jews, blacks or lesbians funny.
Now, before some of you head off to Google to find out what a Dirty Sanchez is, I want you to do something for me. I want you to aware of how you react when you find out what it is. This is important for it’s something I’m going to come back to later. Be prepared, most people are shocked. Really, really shocked!! And then, when they get over their shock, they are at a complete loss as to how anyone could ever find something like this funny.
So to make things easy for you, here’s a link to the Urban Dictionary, which I should note is filled to brimming with similar phrases.
The Urban Dictionary: Dirty Sanchez
Let’s pause for a moment to absorb what you just read. Why? Because there’s a whole generation of young people out there who find this funny; and for some of us that’s almost impossible to imagine. But the fact remains that within popular culture the Dirty Sanchez is downright ubiquitous. Don’t believe me? Then click on the following YouTube link that provides a collage of some of South Park’s best moments. There’s good stuff here, but to speed things along you can scroll to 5m52s where Mr. MacKey reviews sexual positions with his elementary school class. They include:
Missionary Position
Doggy Style
Pile Driver
The Filthy Sanchez *
Hot Karl (No relation)
* South Park changed the term to ‘Filthy’ because of the following law suit.
It’s important to note this type of humour gains traction in two ways. The first – and I will come back to this in more detail in a moment – is the overwhelming amount of violent porn for which we now have access. The other is that a whole generation of young people can make open reference to astonishingly offensive sexual acts while under the watchful eye of mature authoritarian figures like parents and university presidents.
Donkey Punch! Rusty Trombone! Hunting Paddington! If you’re over 40, you don’t hear it. These terms just whistle right past your ear unnoticed. And guess what … for young people that’s really funny.
Bradley Manning’s WikiLeaks
One of the most astonishing things we learned when Bradley Manning released approximately 250,000 documents to WikiLeaks was that pilots were trading DVDs of their airstrikes like hockey cards. Indeed, the most prized videos were black and white cockpit videos of Iraqi citizens dying under a spray of machine gun fire while the pilot and gunners exchanged humorous banter over top.
Most of us couldn’t believe what we were hearing. These were the people American citizens had sent to defend our democratic freedoms and here they making glib comments as they killed people. But let’s take a moment to consider that maybe this type of response is far more human than we care to realize.
If any of those soldiers had a crise-du-cœur – as Bradley Manning did – they’d be sitting in jail next to him right now. Their democratically elected government mandated them to commit these acts. And as a result all of them had to find some way to rectify their role in violence playing out on the screens in front of them. Anyone who’s had a chance to review the comments of the Dalhousie dentistry students’ ‘Gentlemen’s Club’ will find eerie similarities.
So let’s bring this back to porn. If you’re a male, who at the beginning of this piece didn’t know what a Dirty Sanchez was, then your sexual coming of age was framed by what you saw in Playboy, Penthouse and Cheri magazines. Tame stuff by current standards. In fact, since these magazines were hard to get, you probably traded them like hockey cards just like those American soldiers.
But if you do know what a Dirty Sanchez is, then there’s a darn good chance your adolescence was spent marinating in some of the most graphic and violent sexual images ever produced in the history of humankind. Indeed, research shows that young men between the ages of 15 and 25 are the greatest consumers of this porn.
What’s worrying is that other research indicates that pornography’s effect on the brain is no different than heroin. The first hit gives you a rush of dopamine that you can never quite catch again. This often results in binge consumption that leads consumers towards more and more graphic images. How does a developing mind cope with this kind of death spiral?
The same way soldiers do: humour.
Jokes about sexualized violence are the modern day equivalent of a black guy, a lesbian and a Jew walking into a bar. Both spring from deeply offensive places. Indeed, for Millennials, it’s just like the 1970s all over again. Only it’s worse for the generational divide — vast as it’s ever been — is no longer seen by most people over forty. We think we’re cool. But unfortunately the new cool is fueled by the violent sexual references that whip past us unnoticed.
So, here’s a question: what happens when the adults finally catch on? Will they think a Dirty Sanchez is funny? Will they see it for what it is: a natural coping mechanism by a generation of young men exposed to more porn than all previous generations combined?
Of course not! The adults are going to be shocked! Shocked right down to their core. And, no, they’re aren’t going to understand. Nor are they going to assume any responsibility for this. Instead they are are going to conspire to make an example of the first idiot to get caught standing in this generational no man’s land.
Je Suis Charlie Hebdo
Let’s put this right on the table: I feel really bad for Richard Florizone. Why? Because the gulf between our expectations for a civic response to the Dalhousie Dentistry School scandal compared to the response we have for our educational leaders is quite frankly unforgivable.
Last week 17 people in France lost their lives because a satirical magazine exercised its right to publish images considered offensive to Islam. And what has been the response to this? Leaders throughout the Western world have joined ranks. Everyone from Stephen Harper to Barack Obama speak in solidarity for the need to fight any act that attempts to silence our freedom of expression.
Well, guess what! Embedded within our freedom of expression is not only the right to depict offensive cartoons of Mohamed, but to film, broadcast, profit and consume vast quantities of violent pornographic images.
If we were to knock on the doors of our elected officials expecting them to use their considerable legislative abilities to reign in the root causes of the Dalhousie Dentistry scandal, the answer would be no. But Dalhousie University, on the other hand … well, it’s fair game!
So, let’s walk for a few steps in Richard Florizone’s shoes. The Dalhousie Board of Governors recently held an emergency meeting during which they unanimously voted their support of Florizone’s slow, yet measured response to this scandal.
Why?
Because Dalhousie University is perilously close to being locked into a defamation suit it can’t afford. Should things tip just a teensy-weensy bit the wrong way, these 13 ‘gentlemen’ would have grounds to say their careers were destroyed before they even got off the ground. And how much are those careers worth? Let’s assume each one of those students stands to make a modest salary of $200,000 a year. And let’s argue that career would last 35 years. That’s seven million dollars a claimant. And since there are 13 of them Dalhousie could be on the hook for 91 million dollars!
Why?
Because freedom of expression is at work on a multitude of levels in this scandal. If you look at the comments these ‘gentlemen’ made it is clear that many were done while physically standing on Dalhousie property. You’d think that that means the University is responsible for their actions. But wait! The complicating factor is that these comments were probably made on cell phones that these students paid for, over networks with which they had corporate accounts, messages that were in turn channeled into a publicly traded social media site.
In short, these gentlemen were in a private virtual space — a locker room, if you will — on loan to them from a company that has profited handsomely all around from this scandal. The incidents took place on Facebook, and the ensuing rage against these students has been primarily channeled through the same site. Mark Zuckerberg appears to own both sides of this issue … but no one seems to be knocking on his door asking him to do something about this.
There by the Grace of God …
The Dirty Sanchez sprung from a dark and offensive place. People are right to stand up and say, ‘Hey, sexualized violence against women just isn’t funny.’ But if we want Dalhousie to exercise a public blood-letting on our behalf so that we can move on to the next Facebook feed, then nothing will be gained. To the contrary, we need to take a cold, hard look at the darker corners of our right to freedom of expression.
Wondering how dark those corners get? Why don’t you take fifteen minutes out of your day to peruse the following porn sites — tame to depraved — accessible to anyone with an internet connection. But be forewarned. If you thought a Dirty Sanchez was disturbing, these links go much further:
As the father of two young daughters I’m concerned about the world they are about to inherit. Their sexuality will soon be in direct conflict with a disturbing cultural norm. To my surprise the offensive ethic jokes I grew up hearing my parents’ friends shared at parties in the 1970s have mutated into a new genre that is squarely directed at them.
Gone are the days when young men masturbated at night to a stolen Penthouse magazine with a flashlight and the sheets pulled over their heads. The men my children will work with will have had access to every single pornographic image ever made! And that means they will be different than me. If we are going to make this a better world, there are no quick fixes. Indeed, we got a good decade of hard work ahead of us!

